scel, I won't re-post all your eloquent words, but I can totally relate to this particular line.
I'm new to the amazing art of fly fishing, and I learn many new things every day, partially because of trial & error, but also because of online resources such as FFC. ( For example, I had no idea this Forum has been around for so long! )
I am also learning without a mentor, or casting buddy, so I can also relate. I'm sure the local fly shops are sick of my constant questions!
When I started to figure out a little 1000M stretch of the side-channel at SHP, I was torn between telling all because I was so stoked, but also holding a few cards close. Then, of course, I watch a seasoned side-channel angler wade his arse off across river, catch 5 in succession and shrug his shoulders when I get yet another wind knot!
I also agree with the occasional report, especially if it's somewhere unique, or if one is able to get pictures. My thoughts are similar to yours about having just enough difficulty at any spot to make it interesting. I hope that there are still places out there that are 'anonymous' clearwater streams, or bangin' stillwater... maybe most of us still have a few cards left.
Thanks scel.
-M.