Song For A Winter's Night

[flyangler]

I don't loooooove either of these videos, but who sings the song better? Gord or Sarah?

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sle2_E_Xt-c

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J1oiiE7CyZ0...feature=related

[flyangler]

27 looks an NO opinions?

[Brownstone]

make that 28 looks .. could'nt make it 1 min. into the first one .. sorry

[flyangler]

That's a start, ha ha ha!

[Weedy1]

I need to know why you're asking before I comment. Sounds like an inside argument is going on.

[TerryH]

I'm showing my age here by confessing to being a Gordon Lightfoot fan -- I still have a ton of his records (remember what those are?). There's no doubt in my mind, the best video is Lightfoot's -- he wrote the song and he knows how it's supposed to be sung. Terry

[Taco]

Going with Terry here...Gordy L

[SanJuanWorm]

Sarah, cuz shes damn sexy.

[Guest guito]

Gordon L is my choice also, sarahs seemed really slooooow.

 

 

I don't loooooove either of these videos, but who sings the song better? Gord or Sarah?

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sle2_E_Xt-c

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J1oiiE7CyZ0...feature=related

[snakeman]

I haven't heard anyone cover a Lightfoot song and have it sound better than the original. The man is a national treasure.

[ladystrange]

i was going to listen, glad i read further on... i cant stand gordon lightfoot.

 

O.D. when i was a child.

[SilverDoctor]

Lightfoot Twas a fav of mine my by for years. My focus shifted after hearing the haunting Sara Mclachlan version of Wintersong.

Gordons version reminds me of nature's course and missing the one you love.

Sara's is more like unrequited love. Loving the unreachable.

Funny how two artists can say different things with the same words.

[reevesr1]

Sara's is more like unrequited love. Loving the unreachable.

What, like a stripper?

 

Sorry SiverDoctor, but since I had no chance of matching the eloquence, I decided to take another path, one I was more comfortable with.

[flyangler]

I have to admit, I have to keep my eyes closed when I click on either one, but I prefer SMcL's version. Gord sounds like he just wants to get it over with. SilverDoctor and I think alike on this one.

[SilverDoctor]

What, like a stripper?

 

Sorry SiverDoctor, but since I had no chance of matching the eloquence, I decided to take another path, one I was more comfortable with.

 

Eloquence Ea? No more farting at the kitchen table for me, no siree!!!

[rusty]

Gord is pure gold, baby. Would take his version anyday.

 

Far as I'm concerned, Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald may be the greatest tune of all time.