If they are tied at the end of the second outing, it turns into a duel. Each guy puts on a 3 oz streamer and they stand back to back. Take 50 paces turn and cast, first one to give the other a new piercing wins
I am not sure on the tie at the end of the tie breaker, maybe flip a coin? Or skip the tie breaker completely and just flip a coin. I was just looking for another excuse for the wife to get out and fish.....