alhuger

Why would you stick it out for an hour if he was messing your water up as such? I assume that the fishing was good enough not to care? al

I was lucky enough to fish the 13'5" 720 grain for a full day (thanks Brian). It's a *fantastic* stick. It can move a ridiculous amount of line (and that mattered where we were at the time) and play nice big fish really well. It's got plenty of strength so you can play large fish but still feel every movement or head shake on smaller fish. If your in the market for this sort of rod you should give it a shot it's got a pretty unique feel to it. I did not get to fish the 520 but if it's anything like the 720 I am buying one at some point. Cheers, al

That is cool, I would not have thought of using the scandi but that makes perfect sense. I will have to try that. Which switch did you go with? al

All, I'm looking at a new rod for summer runs and chum. I like the price of the Temple Fork 7/8 130 4 Deer Creek 7/8 Wt. 13'-0. Any opinions on it? I have a DC 12.6 5/6 which I really like. Is the action similar? Also, any feedback on line recommendations would be appreciated. The grain window they publish looks quite wide, makes me wonder if it's closer to an 8 than a 7, I know my 5/6 is certainly more 6 than 5 (if not 7). al

Wow. You are officially my bow river hero. This and that massive bow a couple of years back. Truly awesome.

Oh my. That would have been phenomenal. Awesome fish.

That is awesome, what was the fight like? al

Awesome Keith, thanks!

All, I've been tying sculpins lately on tubes for the bow. Problem is though I realized I have no idea what sculpins tend to look like size wise in the summer months on the bow or frankly, in general. My only experience with them on the bow is in the fall when I have seen them up 3-4 inches or more and typically in the late evening is when I see them. Any insight is welcome. al

I am now vaguely embarrassed about keeping photos on my iphone of fish.

Lots of thoughtful commentary on this thread, which is cool. For my part, I pumped once and I botched it. Likely killed the fish. I no longer pump. I see plenty of guys do it though (especially in Jack's neck of the woods and there about) and I see plenty of dudes there fumble the fish as well. Makes me a wee bit uncomfortable. I personally would not do it but that's because I do not trust myself. Also, the argument that 'biologists' do it and therefore it's safe does not wash with me. I've watched and fished with biologists and seen fish 'mishandling'. Maybe that's because they know the fish are more durable than we (without the benefit of a formal education in it) seem to think. Or maybe they get overly familiar with fish handling and get a little cavalier with it all. al

Thanks Jack.

I echo Marc on the 5126 Z-Axis. I *love* that stick. I also like the Deer Creek TFO 12.6 5 wt.

The poke dumps all the line in front of you so the act of picking it up loads your rod. You can power out a cast without as much of a d loop required. Or so I think. I tend to do it when I am situations like that because it gets the line in front of me so I can perform a cast, perhaps it's more of a roll cast now that I think of it (mine, not the actual poke). You can definitely reach cast with a spey rod, I am sure you can perform pretty much any cast you wanted to. al

I've seen it in the video but I am at a loss to describe it properly, I think the speypages descriptions suck as well but I generally have a hard time visualizing this stuff from reading it. .I think a perry poke works just as well in most situations and it's a lot easier to perform IMO. al

I suppose it could be subjective but I think in general winter trout need to conserve energy to live through a time of abbreviated food access. Hence less fight as their metabolism drops off in order to get through winter. Or I think anyhow. Could be I just get into the lame fish.

I am not a huge fan of winter fishing for trout. I find the fight sluggish and pretty unrewarding. Of course, I still do it because I cannot help myself but I tend to do it less because of the lethargic fight. However, I find that smaller, younger fish (especially bows) seem to have *a lot* more fight in them than their larger counterparts. Anyone know why that is? Is it because they have less mass and are more aggressive in order to see it through the winter months? al

I remember my grandfather doing that so I suspect it's common (or was) here in AB. I know gear guys catch them at night on the Shuswap all the time too, rather large ones in there. I suspect they use scented bait for them there which makes me think Max is right about them hunting at least in part by smell. al

I catch fish on the fly in 15 feet or more (often much more) all the time. Does it matter how long it takes to get the fly there? If I was in a hurry I would be at work, not fishing. al

Awesome, thanks.

Hey Jack, Is there a link for a recorded version of the first show? -al

Those are wonderful. You must be proud. al

How can you tell it's a hen?

Facts and zealotry rarely share the same house dude. It's easier to make broad based assertions (no matter how feeble or soft they are) than actually stand up your arguments with fact. Facts are for liberals & left wing pinkos. al

I've been thinking lately about why I keep my rod in certain positions when I hook up and I realized I do a lot of it because I was taught to or because I learned to do it from watching more experienced anglers. In most cases I do not actually know why I do it, or what benefit it has. I thought I would run through the things I do (now by rote) and get your feedback. In the River - Sea Run When I fish anadromous fish after a hook up I keep my rod tip low and to the side. I do this because I've been told to and because I think it lets the fish fight the rod and avoid straight lining itself into an early break off. When I get the fish close I raise my rod to keep the fish off the rocks and riverbed. I also have have been told this gets the fish to fight my line (as it's all in the drink) but if they run downstream after I hook up (as they typically do) I am not sure how much truth is in that because the line is extended to nearly straight pretty quick. In the River - Trout I always keep my rod tip up unless I am turning a fish to go somewhere I want it. Not sure why I do this differently than when I fish sea run fish. I tried this summer to keep my rod tip low and I did not seem to release any more than usual. In the Lake I always keep my rod tip up. Seems to me this keeps keeps the fish pointed at my boat and is easier to bring in this way. I learned to lake fish on my own though so I'm worried I might have this one wrong although over the years I've done it I've not had an early release problem per se. In the Salt Flats fishing I keep my tip up so I can avoid my fish abrading the leader on coral etc. I have never caught a 'big' fish in the salt though (warm water anyhow) so I've no idea how you fight like a tarpon or striper etc. Any thoughts would be welcome guys. al